Composite X-ray and optical image of SDSS J0849+1114, a trio of merging galaxies though to contain three active galactic nuclei — an extremely rare configuration. Credit: X-ray: NASA/CXC/George Mason Univ./R. Pfeifle et al.; Optical: SDSS & NASA/STScI)
Authors: Xiaoyu Xu (许啸宇) et al.
First Author’s Institution: Nanjing University
Status: Published in ApJ
When Galaxies Collide
Peering into the Triple Core with VLT/MUSE
What They Found: Gas Tails and Outflows
1. Galactic-Scale Tidal Tails
2. Two Distinct Outflows Driven by Radio Jets
First Author’s Institution: Nanjing University
Status: Published in ApJ
When Galaxies Collide
Galaxies are social creatures; they interact and merge (more astrobites talking about this are here and here)! When galaxies collide, the gravitational chaos acts like a funnel, driving massive amounts of cold gas toward the center. This gas rush has two major consequences: it triggers intense bursts of star formation (known as starbursts), and it feeds the central supermassive black holes, activating them as active galactic nuclei (AGNs).
But the story doesn’t end there. These powerful AGNs don’t just sit and feast on the gas. They launch high-velocity winds or jets that push back against the incoming gas, a process known as AGN feedback. (Read more about it in Astrobites here and here.) This feedback is thought to be the key mechanism by which supermassive black holes regulate their host galaxies, either by heating and expelling the gas (negative feedback, which starves star formation) or, in some cases, by compressing it (positive feedback, which promotes star formation).
While binary AGNs (two AGNs in one merging system) are rare, finding systems with three AGNs in one system is fascinatingly rare. The galaxy SDSS J0849+1114 (J0849+1114) is one such system, featuring three Seyfert 2 AGNs, a type of active galaxy with a bright, compact nucleus whose spectrum shows only narrow emission lines, within a tight region of about 5 kiloparsecs (kpc) or 16,000 light-years. Studying this system gives us a front-row seat to how multiple black holes interact and regulate their host environment during a complex merger. Very Large Array observations reveal that nucleus A (see Figure 1) contains two jets, inner and outer. In contrast, nucleus C has one jet, providing further evidence for the presence of an AGN.
But the story doesn’t end there. These powerful AGNs don’t just sit and feast on the gas. They launch high-velocity winds or jets that push back against the incoming gas, a process known as AGN feedback. (Read more about it in Astrobites here and here.) This feedback is thought to be the key mechanism by which supermassive black holes regulate their host galaxies, either by heating and expelling the gas (negative feedback, which starves star formation) or, in some cases, by compressing it (positive feedback, which promotes star formation).
While binary AGNs (two AGNs in one merging system) are rare, finding systems with three AGNs in one system is fascinatingly rare. The galaxy SDSS J0849+1114 (J0849+1114) is one such system, featuring three Seyfert 2 AGNs, a type of active galaxy with a bright, compact nucleus whose spectrum shows only narrow emission lines, within a tight region of about 5 kiloparsecs (kpc) or 16,000 light-years. Studying this system gives us a front-row seat to how multiple black holes interact and regulate their host environment during a complex merger. Very Large Array observations reveal that nucleus A (see Figure 1) contains two jets, inner and outer. In contrast, nucleus C has one jet, providing further evidence for the presence of an AGN.
Figure 1: Left: Hubble Space Telescope image taken in ultraviolet light. Right: Optical image from the VLT/MUSE instrument. The three black holes, nuclei A, B, and C, are marked with black crosses. The white contours are from Hubble, like on the left, and the yellow contours are of the MUSE instrument. We can observe the complex and disturbed morphology resulting from the ongoing merger. Adapted from Xu et al. 2025
Peering into the Triple Core with VLT/MUSE
To understand the gas dynamics in J0849+1114, the authors used the Very Large Telescope (VLT) and its Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) instrument. MUSE is an integral-field spectrograph, meaning it provides spectra for every single spatial pixel (or “spaxel”) across the field of view. This allows astronomers to map not just where the light is coming from, but how the gas is moving and what is causing it to glow, all resolved spatially across the galaxy
The main technique employed was two-component Gaussian fitting of key emission lines like hydrogen alpha (Hα) and ionized oxygen ([O III]λλ4959,5007), which can be seen in Figure 2. The width of a Gaussian line (or its velocity dispersion) in a spectrum tells us how fast the gas is moving. A narrow line means the gas is relatively calm, with most of it moving at similar speeds. A broader line, on the other hand, means the gas velocities are more spread out — some parts are racing toward us, others away — indicating turbulence or outflows. By comparing the widths of different components, astronomers can separate quiet, rotating gas from the high-speed winds launched by the active black holes.
The main technique employed was two-component Gaussian fitting of key emission lines like hydrogen alpha (Hα) and ionized oxygen ([O III]λλ4959,5007), which can be seen in Figure 2. The width of a Gaussian line (or its velocity dispersion) in a spectrum tells us how fast the gas is moving. A narrow line means the gas is relatively calm, with most of it moving at similar speeds. A broader line, on the other hand, means the gas velocities are more spread out — some parts are racing toward us, others away — indicating turbulence or outflows. By comparing the widths of different components, astronomers can separate quiet, rotating gas from the high-speed winds launched by the active black holes.
Figure 2: Zoomed-in spectra showing the Hβ and [O III] (left) and Hα, [N II], and [S II] (right) emission lines from the spot marked with an “X” in the MUSE image in Figure 1. The blue line shows the observed data, the orange line shows the best-fit model, and the two colored curves (light blue and red) represent the two components of the gas. The pink line shows the leftover differences between the data and the model. The First Component is narrow, representing gas that is relatively settled, often showing signs of rotation or slow movements associated with gravitational disturbances, like tidal tails (low velocity dispersion, σ1 ≤ 50 km/s). The Second Component is broad, representing highly turbulent or fast-moving gas, characteristic of powerful outflows or winds driven by the central AGNs (high velocity dispersion, σ2 > σ1). Adapted from Xu et al. 2025
What They Found: Gas Tails and Outflows
The VLT/MUSE observations successfully characterized both the undisturbed (First Component) and turbulent (Second Component) gas across the system.
1. Galactic-Scale Tidal Tails
The slow-moving gas (First Component) revealed extended structures of ionized gas stretching over 10 kpc (33,000 light-years), and in some directions, even more than 15 kpc (49,000 light-years) away from nucleus A. These large, low-velocity gas clouds align well with features known as tidal tails: the stretched-out arms of gas and stars pulled away by the violent gravitational forces of the merger.
2. Two Distinct Outflows Driven by Radio Jets
The fast-moving gas (Second Component) clearly showed two distinct sites: outflows originating from nucleus A and nucleus C.
- Outflow A: This outflow extends over 5 kpc (16,000 light-years) around nucleus A. The gas kinematics and geometry strongly suggest that this outflow is being driven by nucleus A’s radio jet. This finding is key, as the measured kinetic power of the outflow is about 10 times stronger than what star formation alone could supply, and the current luminosity of the AGN is also insufficient to power it.
- Outflow C: A smaller but detectable outflow extends about 5.9 kpc (19,000 light-years) around nucleus C, with a lower kinetic power compared to Outflow A. But, like Outflow A, the energetics and velocity gradients suggest this outflow is also linked to nucleus C’s radio jet.
A Black Hole That’s Recently Gone Quiet
The most striking implication of this study relates to the timing of nucleus A’s activity. The presence of extended ionized gas far from the nucleus (in the tidal tails, >10 kpc or 33,000 light-years away) provides a fascinating glimpse into the AGN’s recent past.
The physical conditions of this distant gas were determined using emission line ratios ([O III]/Hα and [N II]/Hα) on the Baldwin, Phillips, and Terlevich (BPT) diagram. A BPT diagram uses emission line ratios to diagnose the energy source that ionizes the gas: star formation, AGN, or shocks. The BPT diagram of J0849+1114 indicates that an AGN currently photoionizes the gas.
By running sophisticated photoionization models, the scientists calculated how luminous nucleus A must have been to ionize the gas currently found 10–15 kpc (33,000–49,000 light-years) away. They discovered that this required nucleus A to be 20–100 times more luminous than it currently is! Since light takes time to travel, and the ionized gas quickly recombines (on timescales of less than 100 years for this gas), this luminous phase must have ended very recently, approximately 30,000–50,000 years ago. This is a long time for us, but just a blink of an eye on cosmic timescales.
The physical conditions of this distant gas were determined using emission line ratios ([O III]/Hα and [N II]/Hα) on the Baldwin, Phillips, and Terlevich (BPT) diagram. A BPT diagram uses emission line ratios to diagnose the energy source that ionizes the gas: star formation, AGN, or shocks. The BPT diagram of J0849+1114 indicates that an AGN currently photoionizes the gas.
By running sophisticated photoionization models, the scientists calculated how luminous nucleus A must have been to ionize the gas currently found 10–15 kpc (33,000–49,000 light-years) away. They discovered that this required nucleus A to be 20–100 times more luminous than it currently is! Since light takes time to travel, and the ionized gas quickly recombines (on timescales of less than 100 years for this gas), this luminous phase must have ended very recently, approximately 30,000–50,000 years ago. This is a long time for us, but just a blink of an eye on cosmic timescales.
The Episode of Self-Regulation
By integrating the findings across different wavelengths and timescales, the current faint luminosity state, the past luminous state inferred from the distant gas, and the presence of radio jets of different ages, the authors propose a model of episodic AGN feedback in nucleus A:
1. Past Activity (150,000 years ago): An active phase likely launched an outer radio jet, which subsequently drove the large-scale ionized gas outflow observed today.
2. Peak Ionization (30,000–50,000 years ago): A subsequent burst of high accretion reached its peak, ionizing the distant tidal tails.
3. Fading and Quenching (Today): The energy released by the jet and/or outflow during the active phase likely expelled or heated the surrounding gas (negative feedback), causing the central accretion disk to run out of fuel. The AGN has since faded rapidly to its current low-accretion state, marked by the appearance of a young inner radio jet.
1. Past Activity (150,000 years ago): An active phase likely launched an outer radio jet, which subsequently drove the large-scale ionized gas outflow observed today.
2. Peak Ionization (30,000–50,000 years ago): A subsequent burst of high accretion reached its peak, ionizing the distant tidal tails.
3. Fading and Quenching (Today): The energy released by the jet and/or outflow during the active phase likely expelled or heated the surrounding gas (negative feedback), causing the central accretion disk to run out of fuel. The AGN has since faded rapidly to its current low-accretion state, marked by the appearance of a young inner radio jet.
A Quiet Ending After a Loud Beginning
J0849+1114 is not just a statistical anomaly as a triple AGN candidate; it serves as a crucial case study demonstrating the powerful and rapid effects of AGN feedback. High-resolution observations confirm that violent galaxy mergers trigger both powerful outflows and episodic bursts of extreme luminosity. Crucially, these outflows clear the gas and cause the central supermassive black hole to quickly fade from a luminous quasar phase to a quiet, low-accretion state within tens of thousands of years. This system provides strong, spatially resolved evidence that AGN feedback rapidly suppresses accretion onto the supermassive black hole and shapes the host galaxy on kiloparsec scales during the chaotic drama of galactic mergers.
Original astrobite edited by Lindsey Gordon.
About the author, Sowkhya Shanbhog:
I am currently a first-year PhD student at Scuola Normale Superiore in Pisa, Italy, where I am focusing on studying high-redshift quasars. Prior to this, I completed a dual BS-MS degree at the Indian Institute of Science Education and Research in Pune, India. Now, I am eager to expand my involvement in science communication and outreach initiatives. I have recently developed an interest in cooking, particularly since moving to a new city. I find solace in listening to music during my leisure time.
Editor’s Note: Astrobites is a graduate-student-run organization that digests astrophysical literature for undergraduate students. As part of the partnership between the AAS and astrobites, we occasionally repost astrobites content here at AAS Nova. We hope you enjoy this post from astrobites; the original can be viewed at astrobites.org.
