Releases from NASA, HubbleSite, Spitzer, ESO, ESA, NASA’s Chandra X-ray Observatory, Royal Astronomical Society, Harvard-Smithsonian Center For Astrophysics, Max Planck Institute, Gemini Observatory, Subaru Telescope, W. M. Keck Observatory, JPL-Caltech, ICRAR, Webb Space Telescope, etc
Rare or unusual astrophysical objects are used to test the limits of theoretical models because of their extreme properties. The bright X-ray source SS433 in our galaxy undoubtedly belongs to this category. Initially identified as an Hα emitter, it was later recognised as a black hole in a binary system. Since then, SS433, which emits strongly in the radio and X-ray bands, has been targeted by almost every space- and ground-based observatory, leading to a flurry of discoveries. In contrast, the surrounding huge W50 nebula, spanning more than two degrees, is much fainter and difficult to study. The complete radio image earned W50 the nickname 'Manatee Nebula', while X-ray maps were mostly patches from different observatories or lacked spatial or energy resolution. This shortcoming has finally been overcome by the recently published SRG/eROSITA map of W50 in multiple X-ray colours, which reveals a beautiful blend of thermal and non-thermal processes within an elongated cocoon.
At the core of the W50 nebula lies a compact source (most likely a stellar-mass black hole) that accretes matter from a companion star at an astonishingly high rate — thousands of times greater than the amount the black hole can digest. This limiting rate (known as the Eddington accretion rate) arises due to the pressure exerted by the radiation produced by the infalling gas. This configuration has an immediate impact on the observational appearance of the compact source and its large-scale environment. The key prediction of the accretion theory is that most of the gas supplied to the black hole will be expelled from
the system, depositing a large amount of energy into the ambient medium in the process (see Highlight September 2024).
The W50 nebula is well known in radio astronomy for its croissant-like shape. Mapping this large nebula in X-rays used to be
problematic due to the limited field of view of space telescopes. Additionally, strong and inhomogeneous absorption by gas and dust occurs in the direction of W50, which is located just two degrees away from the Galactic Plane. These problems can be resolved by using a telescope with a large field of view and high sensitivity to diffuse emission — the very characteristics of the eROSITA telescope on board the SRG observatory.
The full-size X-ray map of the W50 nebula is shown in Fig. 1. The central bright spot is the black hole that powers the entire nebula. It appears extended because it is much brighter than the nebula emission, causing the central part of the image to become saturated.
The 'X-ray colours' in this figure serve the same role as red, green, and blue colours in visible light. Specifically, red
corresponds to X-ray photons with a longer wavelength, while green and blue correspond to progressively shorter wavelengths. Remarkably, this simple approach immediately reveals the nature of the X-ray emission: red and yellow colours dominate where thermal plasma with a temperature of 2–10 million degrees is present. Conversely, in the bluer regions, non-thermal emission from relativistic particles dominates.
The nebula is clearly asymmetric, most likely due to a gradient in the ambient gas density surrounding it. The most remarkable feature is the so-called 'Extended X-ray Jets' (EXJs), which have sharp inner edges located around 25 parsecs from the central black hole SS433. Their spectra do not have the emission lines characteristic of thermal plasma. Rather, they must be due to the emission of relativistic particles accelerated by shocks powered by SS433’s outflows. These structures have recently been detected at TeV energies; each TeV photon carries a billion times more energy than a soft X-ray photon at keV energies.
These new X-ray data support the idea that the energy flow from SS433 evolves through three distinct stages:
1) an invisible 'dark' flow of energy between the black hole and the EXJs,
presumably carried by a cold wind from the binary system;
2) a 'non-thermal' flow of energy over some 30 pc in the form of EXJs; and
3) a thermal flow (i.e., shock-heated interstellar medium (ISM)) that envelops the EXJs.
The thermal part of the W50 X-ray emission can be reasonably well described by a shock-heated plasma that has not yet reached temperature and ionisation equilibrium. Such emission is typical of middle-aged or old supernova remnants (SNRs). The outer radio boundary of the nebula also resembles SNR shocks (see Fig. 2).
In contrast, the 'extended X-ray jets' are the most remarkable features of this system on tens-of-pc scales. Their sharp inner edges plausibly correspond to extreme shocks that accelerate particles and power the X-ray (synchrotron) and TeV emission, which is 9–10 orders of magnitude more energetic. The W50/SS433 system clearly illustrates the important role that hyper-Eddington accretors might play in the energetics of the interstellar medium in galaxies at different redshifts, as well as in the production of ultra-high-energy particles.
Radio image of the S-shaped precessing jet launched by the neutron star in
Circinus X-1. Both Cir X-1 itself (centre of the image) and a background
source have been subtracted from the image to make the S-shape clearer.
The jets are fast, narrow flows of material outwards from Cir X-1. The
size of the jets against the sky is the same apparent size as a penny
viewed from 100 metres away, but their real size is greater than five
light-years. Credit:Fraser Cowie
A strange 'garden sprinkler-like' jet coming from a neutron star has been pictured for the first time.
The S-shaped structure is created as the jet changes direction due to the wobbling of the disc of hot gas around the star – a process called precession, which has been observed with black holes but, until now, never with neutron stars.
This particular object sits in the binary system Circinus X-1 more than 30,000 light-years from Earth and formed from the core of a massive supergiant star that collapsed around the same time Stonehenge was built.
It is so dense that a teaspoon of its material weighs as much as Mount Everest.
Binary systems have two stars that are bound together by gravity. In the case of Circinus X-1, one of these is a neutron star.
Both neutron stars and black holes are cosmological monsters which form when the biggest stars in the Universe die and collapse under their own gravity.
However, the latter are considerably more massive and can only be detected through their gravitational effects, while the former can be observed directly despite their denseness.
They are some of the most extreme objects in the Universe and have interiors almost entirely made of neutrons.
Radio image from the MeerKAT telescope showing Circinus X-1 in the centre,
within the spherical remnant of the supernova it was born in. The
shockwaves caused by the jets are seen above and below Cir X-1, and the
S-shape structure in the jets is somewhat obscured by a bright source in
the background. Credit: Fraser Cowie
The jet emanating from the neutron star was spotted by a team of
astronomers at the University of Oxford, who used MeerKAT - a radio
telescope in South Africa - to create the most detailed, high-resolution
images of Circinus X-1.
The pictures, which were presented at this week’s National Astronomy Meeting at the University of Hull,
include the first-ever image of an S-shaped jet coming from a confirmed
neutron star – a breakthrough that could help unravel the extreme
physics behind the astronomical phenomenon.
Lead researcher Fraser Cowie said there was another system known for its S-shaped jets, called
SS433, but recent results suggest that object is likely a black hole.
"This image is the first time we have seen strong evidence for a precessing jet from a confirmed neutron star," he said.
"This evidence comes from both the symmetric S shape of the radio-emitting
plasma in the jets and from the fast, wide shockwave, which can only be
produced by a jet changing direction.
"This will give valuable information about the extreme physics behind the launching of the jet, a
phenomenon which is still not well understood."
The neutron star's huge density creates a strong force of gravity that strips gas
from the companion star, forming a disc of hot gas around it that
spirals down towards its surface.
This process, called accretion, releases huge amounts of energy per second with more power than a
million Suns. Some of this energy powers jets – narrow beams of
outflowing material from the binary system travelling close to the speed
of light.
Recent upgrades to the MeerKAT telescope have resulted in excellent sensitivity and higher-resolution images. With these the team saw clear evidence of an S-shaped structure, similar in shape to water spraying from a garden sprinkler, in Circinus X-1's jet.
Not only that, but researchers also discovered moving termination shocks – the first recorded from an X-ray binary. These are regions where the jet violently rams into the surrounding material, causing a shockwave.
Cowie's team measured the waves moving at roughly 10 per cent of the speed of light, confirming that they were caused by the fast-moving jet and not something slower such as a wind of material from the stars.
"The fact that these shockwaves span a wide angle agrees with our model," Cowie said. "So we have two strong pieces of evidence telling us the neutron star jet is precessing."
Measuring the velocity of the shockwaves will also help astronomers understand what the jet causing them is made from.
The shockwaves effectively act as particle accelerators in space - producing high-energy cosmic rays - and the maximum energy of particles that can be accelerated depends on their velocity.
"Circinus X-1 is one of the brightest objects in the X-ray sky and has been studied for over half a century," Cowie said. "But despite this, it remains one of the most enigmatic systems we know of.
"Several aspects of its behaviour are not well explained so it's very rewarding to help shed new light on this system, building on 50 years of work from others."
He added: "The next steps will be to continue to monitor the jets and see if they change over time in the way we expect.
"This will allow us to more precisely measure their properties and continue to learn more about this puzzling object."
The research was performed as part of the X-KAT and ThunderKAT projects on the MeerKAT telescope operated by the South African Radio Astronomy Observatory (SARAO). The observations were carried out using the recently installed S-band receivers provided by the Max-Planck Institute (MPG).
Caption: Radio image of the S-shaped precessing jet launched by the neutron star
in Circinus X-1. Both Cir X-1 itself (centre of the image) and a
background source have been subtracted from the image to make the
S-shape clearer. The jets are fast, narrow flows of material outwards
from Cir X-1. The size of the jets against the sky is the same apparent
size as a penny viewed from 100 metres away, but their real size is
greater than five light-years. Credit: Fraser Cowie
Caption: Radio image from the MeerKAT telescope showing Circinus X-1 in the
centre, within the spherical remnant of the supernova it was born in.
The shockwaves caused by the jets are seen above and below Cir X-1, and
the S-shape structure in the jets is somewhat obscured by a bright
source in the background. Credit: Fraser Cowie
Caption: GIF of moving termination shocks from Circinus-1. These are regions
where the jet violently rams into the surrounding material causing a
shockwave travelling at a significant fraction of the speed of light. Credit: Fraser Cowie
Further information
Circinus X-1 lies in the constellation Circinus, a small, faint constellation
that can be observed in the southern sky. It was first noted by French
astronomer Nicolas-Louis de Lacaille in 1756. The name ‘Circinus’ is
Latin for ‘compass’, referring to the drafting tool.
In July 2007, observations of Circinus X-1 revealed the system is highly luminous in
X-rays and emits jets normally found in black hole systems – the first
of this kind discovered to display this similarity to black holes. This
makes Circinus X-1 a peculiar system that defies conventional
classification. Discovered in the late 1960s, it has shown variation
over several orders of magnitude in X-ray and radio on time periods from
hours to decades. Strong evidence suggests it is surrounded by its
natal supernova remnant, aged at ~4000 years, making Circinus X-1 the
youngest known X-ray binary star system. This provides a unique, complex
laboratory for astronomers to test their knowledge of accretion, jets,
jet interactions with surrounding material and much more.
Notes for editors
The NAM 2024 conference is principally sponsored by the Royal Astronomical
Society, the Science and Technology Facilities Council and the
University of Hull.
About the Royal Astronomical Society
The Royal Astronomical Society (RAS), founded in 1820, encourages and
promotes the study of astronomy, solar-system science, geophysics and
closely related branches of science.
The RAS organises scientific meetings, publishes international research and review journals,
recognises outstanding achievements by the award of medals and prizes,
maintains an extensive library, supports education through grants and
outreach activities and represents UK astronomy nationally and
internationally. Its more than 4,000 members (Fellows), a third based
overseas, include scientific researchers in universities, observatories
and laboratories as well as historians of astronomy and others.
The RAS accepts papers for its journals based on the principle of peer
review, in which fellow experts on the editorial boards accept the paper
as worth considering. The Society issues press releases based on a
similar principle, but the organisations and scientists concerned have
overall responsibility for their content.
About the Science and Technology Facilities Council
The Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC)
is part of UK Research and Innovation – the UK body which works in
partnership with universities, research organisations, businesses,
charities, and government to create the best possible environment for
research and innovation to flourish.
STFC funds and supports research in particle and nuclear physics, astronomy, gravitational
research and astrophysics, and space science and also operates a network
of five national laboratories, including the Rutherford Appleton
Laboratory and the Daresbury Laboratory, as well as supporting UK
research at a number of international research facilities including
CERN, FERMILAB, theESO telescopes in Chile and many more.
STFC's Astronomy and Space Science programme provides support for a wide range
of facilities, research groups and individuals in order to investigate
some of the highest priority questions in astrophysics, cosmology and
solar system science.
STFC's astronomy and space science programme
is delivered through grant funding for research activities, and also
through support of technical activities at STFC's UK Astronomy
Technology Centre and RAL Space at the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory.
STFC also supports UK astronomy through the international European
Southern Observatory and the Square Kilometre Array Organisation.
The E.A. Milne Centre for Astrophysics at the University of Hull brings
together experts who study the evolution of structure in the
Universe ranging from stars through to galaxies and galaxy clusters,
right up to the largest structures in the cosmos.
The centre employs observations, theory and computational methods in collaboration
with international partners. Postgraduate and undergraduate students
work alongside staff to understand the wonders of the Universe. Through a
series of outreach activities, the centre also aims to share its
passion for astronomy and astrophysics with the region and beyond.
Credit: X-ray: (IXPE): NASA/MSFC/IXPE; (Chandra): NASA/CXC/SAO; (XMM): ESA/XMM-Newton; IR: NASA/JPL/Caltech/WISE; Radio: NRAO/AUI/NSF/VLA/B. Saxton. (IR/Radio image created with data from M. Goss, et al.); Image Processing/compositing: NASA/CXC/SAO/N. Wolk & K. Arcand
This composite image of the Manatee Nebula captures the jet emanating from SS 433, a black hole pulling material inwards that is embedded in the supernova remnant which spawned it. Radio emission from the supernova remnant are blue-green, whereas the X-ray from IXPE, XMM-Newton and Chandra are highlighted in bright blue-purple and pink-white set against a backdrop of infrared data in red. The black hole emits twin jets of matter traveling in opposite directions at nearly the speed of light.
These jets distort the remnant’s shape into one astronomers dubbed the Manatee. The jets become bright about 100 light-years away from the black hole, where particles are accelerated to very high energies by shocks within the jet. The IXPE data shows that the magnetic
field, which plays a key role in how particles are accelerated, is aligned parallel to the jet — aiding our understanding of how astrophysical jets accelerate these particles to high energies.
Microquasar SS 433 sits in the center of the supernova remnant W50 in the constellation Aquila, some 18,000 light-years from Earth. SS 433’s powerful jets, which distort the remnant’s shape and earned it the nickname the “Manatee Nebula,” have been clocked at roughly 26% of the speed of light, or more than 48,000 miles per second.
Credit: X-ray: (IXPE): NASA/MSFC/IXPE; (Chandra): NASA/CXC/SAO; (XMM): ESA/XMM-Newton; IR: NASA/JPL/Caltech/WISE; Radio: NRAO/AUI/NSF/VLA/B. Saxton. (IR/Radio image created with data from M. Goss, et al.); Image Processing/compositing: NASA/CXC/SAO/N. Wolk & K. Arcand)
A new paper, detailing IXPE’s observations at SS 433, is available in the latest edition of The Astrophysical Journal.
IXPE is a collaboration between NASA and the Italian Space Agency with
partners and science collaborators in 12 countries. IXPE is led by
NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center. Ball Aerospace, headquartered in
Broomfield, Colorado, manages spacecraft operations together with the
University of Colorado’s Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics in
Boulder.
NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center manages the Chandra program. The
Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory's Chandra X-ray Center controls
science operations from Cambridge, Massachusetts, and flight operations
from Burlington, Massachusetts.
This composite image shows SS 433, a black hole embedded in a supernova remnant. The shape of the supernova remnant resembles the shape of a marine mammal known as the manatee, earning the remnant the nickname, the Manatee Nebula.
The manatee-like structure is oriented with its head toward the right side of the image, and its paddle-shaped tail toward the left side of the image, appearing as a somewhat transparent cloud of bluish-green. In the middle of the remnant is a bright white dot. This dot is black hole SS 433.
Farther toward our left, just above what would be the animal's tail, is an area mostly devoid of material. Here, jets of matter detected in X-ray light are purple-blue, with the black hole detected in X-ray light in pink. The jets are traveling in the opposite direction from the black hole at extreme speeds, causing distortion in the shape of the remnant.
The background of the image features a multitude of white flecks and wispy red streaks, stars and material glowing in infrared light.
Fast Facts for SS 433:
Scale: Image is about 110 arcmin (570 light-years) across. Category:Black Holes Coordinates (J2000): RA 19h 11m 50s | Dec +04° 58´ 42" Constellation:Aquila Observation Dates: June 27, 2000 Observation Time: 2 hours 41 minutes Obs. ID: 659 Instrument:ACIS References: Kaaret, P. et al, 2023,Published Color Code: X-ray: pink, blue, purple; IR: red; Radio: green Distance Estimate: About 18,000 light-years
Nearby spiral galaxy M83 and the MQ1 system with jets, as seen by the
Hubble Space Telescope. The blue circle marks the position of the MQ1
system in the galaxy (shown inset). Image Credits: M83 - NASA, ESA and
the Hubble Heritage Team (WFC3/UVIS, STScI-PRC14-04a).MQ1 inset - W. P.
Blair (Johns Hopkins University) & R. Soria (ICRAR-Curtin).Click here to enlarge
A team of Australian and American astronomers have been studying
nearby galaxy M83 and have found a new superpowered small black hole,
named MQ1, the first object of its kind to be studied in this much
detail.
Astronomers have found a few compact objects that are as powerful as
MQ1, but have not been able to work out the size of the black hole
contained within them until now.
The team observed the MQ1 system with multiple telescopes and
discovered that it is a standard-sized small black hole, rather than a
slightly bigger version that was theorised to account for all its power.
Curtin University senior research fellow Dr Roberto Soria, who is
part of the International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR)
and led the team investigating MQ1, said it was important to understand
how stars were formed, how they evolved and how they died, within a
spiral shaped galaxy like M83.
“MQ1 is classed as a microquasar - a black hole surrounded by a
bubble of hot gas, which is heated by two jets just outside the black
hole, powerfully shooting out energy in opposite directions, acting like
cosmic sandblasters pushing out on the surrounding gas,” Dr Soria said.
“The significance of the huge jet power measured for MQ1 goes beyond
this particular galaxy: it helps astronomers understand and quantify the
strong effect that black hole jets have on the surrounding gas, which
gets heated and swept away.
“This must have been a significant factor in the early stages of
galaxy evolution, 12 billion years ago, because we have evidence that
powerful black holes like MQ1, which are rare today, were much more
common at the time.”
“By studying microquasars such as MQ1, we get a glimpse of how the
early universe evolved, how fast quasars grew and how much energy black
holes provided to their environment.”As a comparison, the most powerful
microquasar in our galaxy, known as SS433, is about 10 times less
powerful than MQ1.
Although the black hole in MQ1 is only about 100 kilometres wide, the
MQ1 structure - as identified by the Hubble Space Telescope - is much
bigger than our Solar System, as the jets around it extend about 20
light years from either side of the black hole.
Black holes vary in size and are classed as either stellar mass (less
than about 70 times the mass of our Sun) or supermassive (millions of
times the mass of our Sun, like the giant black hole that is located in
the middle of the Milky Way).
MQ1 is a stellar mass black hole and was likely formed when a star died, collapsing to leave behind a compact mass.
The discovery of MQ1 and its characteristics is just one of the
results of the comprehensive study of galaxy M83, a collection of
millions of stars located 15 million light years away from Earth.
M83, the iconic Southern-sky galaxy, is being mapped with the Hubble
Space and Magellan telescopes (detecting visible light), the Chandra
X-ray Observatory (detecting light in X-ray frequencies), the Australia
Telescope Compact Array and the Very Large Array (detecting radio
waves).
ICRAR is a joint venture between Curtin University and The University
of Western Australia which receives funding from the State Government
of Western Australia.
Original Publication:
‘Super-Eddington Mechanical Power of an Accreting Black Hole in M83’ published in Science 27/2/2014.Full text available on request.
This composite image shows a powerful microquasar containing a black hole in the outskirts of the nearby (12.7 million light years) galaxy NGC 7793. The large image contains data from the Chandra X-ray Observatory in red, green and blue, optical data from the Very Large Telescope in light blue, and optical emission by hydrogen ("H-alpha") from the CTIO 1.5-m telescope in gold.
The upper inset shows a close-up of the X-ray image of the microquasar, which is a system containing a stellar-mass black hole being fed by a companion star. Gas swirling toward the black hole forms a disk around the black hole. Twisted magnetic fields in the disk generate strong electromagnetic forces that propel some of the gas away from the disk at high speeds in two jets, creating a huge bubble of hot gas about 1,000 light years across. The faint green/blue source near the middle of the upper inset image corresponds to the position of the black hole, while the red/yellow (upper right) and yellow (lower left) sources correspond to spots where the jets are plowing into surrounding gas and heating it. The nebula produced by energy from the jets is clearly seen in the H-alpha image shown in the lower inset.
Credit: NASA/CXC/Univ of Strasbourg/M. Pakull et al
The jets in the NGC 7793 microquasar are the most powerful ever seen from a stellar-mass black hole and the data show that a surprising amount of energy from the black hole is being carried away by the jets, rather than by radiation from material being pulled inward. The power of the jets is estimated to be about ten times larger than that of the very powerful ones seen from the famous microquasar in our own galaxy, SS433. This system in NGC 7793 is a miniature version of the powerful quasars and radio galaxies, which contain black holes that range from millions to billions of times the mass of the Sun.
A paper describing this work is being published in the July 8th, 2010, issue of Nature. The authors are Manfred Pakull from the University of Strasbourg in France, Roberto Soria from University College London, and Christian Motch, also from the University of Strasbourg.
Fast Facts for NGC 7793:
Scale: Wide field image is 9 arcmin across (about 34,000 light years); Inset image is 45 arcsec wide (about 2,800 light years)