An expanded view of the central part of the cleared region
around LkCa 15, showing a composite of two reconstructed images (blue:
2.1 microns, from November 2010; red: 3.7 microns) for LkCa 15. The
location of the central star is also marked. Credit:Kraus &
Ireland, 2011
Figure 1 – Keck Observatory/NIRC2 image of the Sun-like star LkCa 15
obtained from data taken in November 2009 and retrieved from the Keck
Observatory Archive (top left) and taken in December 2017 (bottom-left).
Both images show two arcs of light consistent with two components of
LkCa 15’s circumstellar disk. The right panels show the 2009 and 2017
images of the innermost arc of light were three planets around LkCa 15.
North is up and east is left in the images. The star is about 500
light-years from Earth. Light around LkCa 15 can be seen as close as ~9
au from the star (dark-blue masked region in the upper-right panel;
Sun-to-Saturn distance); the innermost arc of light extends out to ~0.2”
or ~30 au (Sun-to-Pluto distance). While the combined light from the
simulated planets is blended, the NIRC2 data would show evidence of
their orbital motion if the planets were present in these data. Analysis
of Keck/NIRC2 data shows that most of the light around LkCa 15 comes
from disk material instead of from planets.
W. M. Keck Observatory and Subaru Telescope Data Taken Over Eight Years Solve Planet Formation Mystery
Maunakea, Hawaii – Astronomers using the combined power of two Hawaii telescopes have taken groundbreaking, sharp new images of a distant planetary system that likely resembles a baby version of our solar system.
Using Subaru Telescope and W. M. Keck Observatory, the team obtained and analyzed data for an infant Sun-like star named LkCa 15. Previous studies using an advanced interferometry method had inferred that three infant planets were orbiting this star. However, for this method, determining exactly how much light comes from a planet versus other sources like a disk can be particularly difficult. New Subaru and Keck Observatory data appear to solve this mystery; most of the light thought to come from the three candidate planets appears to originate from a disk of gas and dust.
“LkCa 15 is a highly complex system,” said Thayne Currie, lead author of the study and astrophysicist at NASA-Ames Research Center and the Subaru Telescope. “Prior to analyzing our Keck & Subaru data and given the same prior aperture masking data, we also would have concluded that LkCa 15 has three detected superjovian planets.”
The team’s results will soon be published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters; a preprint is available here: https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.04322 .
LkCa 15 is surrounded by a massive protoplanetary disk made of gas and dust, which are the building blocks of planets. Early analysis of this disk showed it has a large cavity depleted of dust – a tell-tale sign that much of the disk material has already been incorporated into massive, developing planetary embryos, or “protoplanets.” While the study rules out very bright superjovian planets, Currie says it is likely that fainter, less massive planets may be in the LkCa 15 system: perhaps those like Jupiter and Saturn.
“The planets in this infant solar system could actually be a lot more like our own solar system than previously thought. They are certainly there somewhere, possibly embedded in the disk. We will keep trying to find them,” said Currie.
Methodology
The findings were made using high-resolution images of the LkCa 15 system obtained from complementary instruments on Maunakea. At Subaru, researchers used a new cutting-edge planet imaging instrument – the Subaru Coronagraphic Extreme Adaptive Optics (SCExAO) system coupled to the CHARIS integral field spectrograph to obtain extremely sharp images at near-infrared wavelengths. The team also used Keck Observatory’s powerful adaptive optics system and Near-Infrared Camera (NIRC2) to obtain new sharp images at longer, thermal-infrared wavelengths where young planets emit more light.
The team also obtained a ‘before-and-after’ view of the system by accessing the Keck Observatory Archive (KOA) to find NIRC2 data taken for LkCa 15 from 2009 – over eight years before the most recent SCExAO/CHARIS and NIRC2 images. KOA is a publicly accessible repository of all the high-value data obtained at the Observatory and is operated by Keck Observatory in partnership with the NASA Exoplanet Science Institute (NExScI) at Caltech.
The combined data showed that most of the light surrounding LkCa 15 originates from an extended arc-like structure – the visible edge of another component of LkCa 15’s disk. This arc has the same brightness previously attributed to planets around LkCa 15.
The nearly decade-old KOA data for LkCa 15 play a unique role in understanding this planetary system. When compared with new Keck Observatory and Subaru Telescope data, the KOA data also showed that light emitted from LkCa 15’s arc-like structure is static over the course of eight years.
“This is consistent with a fixed, disk-like structure. Without the KOA, we would not have been able to know this key fact,” said Currie.
“It’s great to see this new data from Keck and Subaru combined with data from the KOA,” said John O’Meara, chief scientist at Keck Observatory. “This result shows the importance of the KOA, and is a great demonstration of how new discoveries can be made with ‘old’ data.”
